(My husband is feeling nostalgic- he just found out that Russell Yann passed away). He is so proud of his recipe creation that he asked me to post it on my blog. Turn the stove to low and simmer for 20 minutes. So, I will make again but cut back on brown sugar by half. The water thing is different, but for some reason it works with hot dog sauce. 1 cup ketchup 8 oz. Refrigerate and transfer into a plastic squeeze bottle. Required fields are marked *. But then J Dawgs came along and my world was turned upside down. Ive heard of boiling the meat to get the consistency right. Wow that is awesomeare we close with this one? It can be made from everything from potatoes to beets. Then reduce heat to low and simmer for 5 minutes. Its called Custard Stand chili, the restaurants are Custard Stand. It originates from West Virginia. Forget ketchup and mustard, this easy JDawg's sauce recipe is the key to amazing hot dogs. Step 3 -Drain the fat off the beef and add to the slow cooker. Actually, you can do it better. No condiments can make a cheap chicken/beef/pork hot dog taste amazing. Reduce heat to low; simmer, 60 to 90 minutes, until the sauce reaches a medium consistency that is not too soupy. This was very good! Maybe with a nice, fresh squeezed homemade lemonade! Use a wooden spoon or your hands to break up the beef. Thank you. And by the way, the Amish are not prolific observers of Memorial Day. cup ketchup 2 tsp. The last step of this recipe is as simple as mixing cornstarch and water together to form a slurry and adding it to your coney sauce. Amount is based on available nutrient data. Sorry but I do not have that other recipe. Make sure you buy all beef hot dogs. That couldn't be truer than when it comes to eating a hot dog with this amazing hot dog sauce. onion powder tsp. Add in water. I grew up in Flint, Michigan and Coney dogs are a favorite. Method: stovetop Time: under 30 minutes, Every Coney Island shop has their own unique flavor of sauce. Stir into the meat, and continue to simmer over a low heat for 30 minutes, stirring frequently. Made this recipe exactly by recipe. Hope your family/friends like it. Im from Charleston WV. Your restaurant and my sauce do sound like the same thing dont they Thank you. Thank you. 4th Of July Hot Dog Sauce. My husbands famy is crom Fairmont and thats the first thing we do when we get go town is eat a hot dog!! And, yes, barbecuing outdoors is popular among the Amish and they'll be among the millions this weekend firing up the grill to roast their dogs. Ive made this sauce three times now. Set a large skillet on the stove top over medium high heat. Wrap the hot dogs in foil to keep them warm and to make it more like the real J Dawgs experience! I can get it for you tomorrow if thats ok. I need to try coleslaw next! You have a great weekend too. Thank you. Add garlic and vegan ground beef, cook for around 3 minutes until everything is nicely browned. regular mustard (prepared, not dry mustard). It has a little kick of heat but the sweet balances it. 15-Minute Coney Sauce Recipe. Get that same hot, zippy flavor in everything from deviled eggs to enchiladas. Ill try to research it too. Thank you so much. It has a slightly spicy, tangy flavor that will have people wanting seconds. I think I do. We like it with a bite, but you can adjust it to your taste. Theyve got several stands, I think the 1st 1 was in Flat Woods, WV & then Fairmont. Thank you for the nice comments and the thoughts on pressure canning. Stir frequently to break meat into small pieces. If I run across it, I will certainly pass it on to you. Add a few tablespoons of water, beef broth or a few tablespoons of ketchup. Hot dogs and hamburgers! These ingredients add an extra savory element to the sauce that works perfectly against the sweetness of the ketchup. In a large saucepan, bring water to a boil. Don't forget the extra chopped onions to top off your dogs. Now the suace tastes like candy. He loves a good hotdog loaded up with good stuff! Yum oh yum! Instructions * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet. They do stay a little crunchy. All Rights Reserved. Add the burger mixture to a 2 quart dutch oven; stir in the onion mixture. Ingredients 1 (16 ounce) package hot dogs, cut into bite-size pieces cup bourbon whiskey cup ketchup cup brown sugar Directions Place hot dogs, bourbon whiskey, ketchup, and brown sugar into a saucepan over medium heat. T his recipe does 3 - 4 dogs, double recipe as needed. haha hot dogs, beef, banana peppers, hot dog buns, sauerkraut, onion powder and 10 more. This hot dog coney sauce begins like all others -- with ground beef. If the hot dog chili sauce gets too thick add a splash of water or a touch more ketchup. Method: stovetop Time: 1-2 hours, Made with salt, beef consomme, ground cumin, shortening, bacon fat or margarine, onions, garlic, ground beef, chili powder, bay leaf What worries me about that is that you have to simmer it a long time to cook the grease out. I just tried a copycat chili recipe for Dairy Queenit was NOT DQ chili. If for some reason you dont get it please let me know. He keeps getting the big head when I tell him people gave him good comments!! Comfort food is my specialty, and it is truly my pleasure to share these recipes with you. They are so tasty right? Thanks for sharing! This recipe makes enough for freezing and using later. Lol! I bet it had less grease and was good. Im definitely going to have to try this. Your email address will not be published. I am also looking for the famous B& Ls hotdog sauce from fairmont, WV. Stir in water, and mash ground beef thoroughly with a potato masher. It may look like a sad little package shoved in the back of your freezer, but frozen spinach actually has a lot of culinary uses (and some may surprise you). Once you eat a hot dog using this hot dog sauce recipe on it, there is no going back. When it comes to hot dogs, I'm not sure you could ever have too many condiments. Today, we'll quickly cover everything you need to know to make an easy, one-pan, 15-minute coney sauce at home. They are too hot for me!! Microwave in 1-minute increments, stirring after increment, until the sugar is dissolved. Step 2 Cook over medium-high heat. Thank you for trying it and if was good for you up to that point, please try it again and leave the brown sugar out. Hot Dog Sauce Ketchup Brown Sugar Recipes 7,263 Recipes. I havent eaten from there. Don't miss out! Isnt it amazing the different foods we have in different parts of the country. Saute the ground beef for 10 minutes, or until completely browned and cooked through. Which recipe is it that you would like? More will cook off when it is warmed up. We leave about 1/4 cup. More Amish Sauce Recipes Cook for 3 minutes. Allow these to simmer the last few minutes. Mix all ingredients into a saucepan. And anyway, those hot dog police have probably never had the chance to try the awesomeness that is this copycat recipe for J Dawgs hot dog sauce. Method: stovetop Time: 30-60 minutes, No more plain hot dogs! This search takes into account your taste preferences, pickles, brown sugar, molasses, worcestershire sauce, onion powder and 11 more, Spanish onions, worcestershire sauce, brown sugar, water, Kitchen Bouquet and 3 more, black pepper, pickles, ketchup, sauerkraut, hot dogs, onion powder and 10 more, tomato paste, onion powder, Worcestershire sauce, cumin, garlic powder and 11 more, ground sirloin, dried garlic flakes, kosher salt, chili powder and 12 more, paprika, ground sirloin, onion flakes, onion powder, cold water and 11 more, kosher salt, onion powder, red pepper flakes, worcestershire sauce and 12 more, tomato paste, chili powder, salt, ground beef, ketchup, black pepper and 1 more, water, chili powder, ground beef, black pepper, tomato paste and 2 more, spaghetti sauce, pepper, grated cheese, garlic, cooking oil, hotdog and 7 more, onion powder, water, apple cider vinegar, salt, freshly ground black pepper and 17 more, freshly squeezed lemon juice, cayenne pepper, white distilled vinegar and 19 more, tomato paste, diced onion, ketchup, ground beef, salt, water and 3 more, ketchup, dijon style mustard, brown sugar, root beer, dry mustard, soy sauce, corn starch, minced garlic, ketchup, ground ginger and 4 more, lean ground beef, ketchup, crushed red pepper flakes, dried minced onion and 6 more, apple cider vinegar, ketchup, sugar, ground beef, mustard, onions and 1 more, tomato, brown sauce, tomato juice, horseradish sauce, tomato ketchup and 2 more, tomato paste, chili powder, margarine, pepper, onions, water and 6 more, Worcestershire sauce, pepper, ground beef, garlic, chili powder and 6 more, pepper, ground beef, water, Worcestershire sauce, salt, ketchup and 5 more, tomato sauce, chili powder, cayenne, paprika, butter, seasoned salt and 10 more, chili powder, chili sauce, worcestershire sauce, ketchup, ground cumin and 5 more, beef bouillon granules, hot water, paprika, oregano, pepper, tomato paste and 9 more, beef, ground beef, sugar, chili powder, ketchup, water, yellow onions, chopped onions, ketchup, tomato juice, sugar, lean ground beef and 1 more, turmeric, ketchup, chili pepper, condensed tomato soup, smoked paprika and 6 more, chili powder, ketchup, green bell pepper, bologna, tomato juice and 2 more, green bell pepper, Dale's Steak Seasoning, italian seasoning and 23 more, black pepper, tomato sauce, ketchup, Tabasco Sauce, onions, chili powder and 6 more, garlic, yellow mustard, salt, water, chili powder, ketchup, ground black pepper and 6 more, chili powder, ketchup, crushed red pepper flakes, lean ground beef and 5 more, frank, onion powder, mayonnaise, balsamic vinegar, mayonnaise and 9 more, Smucker's Blackberry Jam, ketchup, pepper, Crisco Pure Vegetable Oil and 5 more, habanero chili pepper, lemon, cinnamon, papaya, pepper, salt and 7 more, currants, cider vinegar, apples, spices, brown sugar, fresh ginger, The Best Hot Dog You Will Ever Eat (JDawgs Special Sauce Copycat), Buffalo Wild Wings Caribbean Jerk Wing Sauce, How to Make Greek Hot Dog Sauce ~ Hot Dog Topper, Ospidillo Cafe Hot Dog Chili Sauce No. Thanks for sharing. With the 4th of July and summer barbecues coming up, you definitely, really, absolutely, mustgive this sauce a try. ketchup, brown sugar, ground chuck, cold water, red pepper flakes and 11 more A&W Hot Dog Sauce CDKitchen green bell pepper, chili powder, bologna, ketchup, onion, tomato juice and 1 more They kind of start to curl up on the grill a bit and get all blistery on the outside. his recipe does 3 - 4 dogs, double recipe as needed. Instructions. Have the heart ground twice it makes the sauce much finer try this if u like it I have a more simple receipt. Thank you, Grandpa Bob! Ill eventually be back to try it. Leave some on to maintain consistency. I never ate any of the Yann Dogs but a family friend grew up with those and fixes them frequently. If you dont think you would like that much sugar, it would be fine to decrease the amount. Ingredients 4 cups water 1-1/2 pounds ground beef 1 medium onion, chopped 1 can (28 ounces) tomato sauce 2 tablespoons brown sugar 1-1/2 teaspoons chili powder 1/2 teaspoon salt 1/4 teaspoon pepper Hot dogs, heated Hot dog buns, split Shop Recipe Powered by Chicory Directions In a large saucepan, bring water to a boil. Besides the sauce, plan to add diced onions and sliced dill pickles to the bun with your dog. I have been looking for a good hot dog sauce. Thats funny!! Add the rest of ingredients and stir and keep on simmer heat for 30 minutes, stirring occasionally. Add in the rest of the broth (may not need all of broth but you will need enough to simmer the chili) Bring to a boil. I get it. salt 1/4 tsp. Instructions. Ill be Pinning! Wipe any drippings away, and return to the heat. Pour the sauce over the smokies and cook on low for 2-3 hours. Reduce the heat to a simmer and cook over low heat for 25-30 minutes. Pam, Love your recipe for Hot Dog Sauce, do you have the recipe for Pearls Hot Dog Sauce as well? The spices were added and simmered slowly. Thank you Bob! It may become too greasy in the crockpot is what I am thinking. This week he experimented with this sauce for the fourthtime and now feels he got it just the way he wants it. Cutting them this way practically doubles the surface area that gets grilled. We didnt think it was too sweet and the crowd we fed it to last night didnt think it was. Place ground meats in a large dutch oven. Small world isnt it. When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. You can also use this sauce to top a burger! Worcestershire sauce 2 Tbsp. I usually add a canned chili that I know isnt anywhere near as good tasting as this recipe sounds! Hi. I posted it really early on. Want to make more magic in your crockpot? Amish Sweet Hot Dog sauce, as the name implies, is a sweet sauce and I LOVE it, I love the way the sweetness tempers the dog and if you top it with some shredded cheese that you are getting this amazing flavor meld. Nutrition info is auto-generated. Stir into the meat, and continue to simmer over a low heat for 30 minutes, stirring frequently. Thanks SO much! Thanks for sharing. Method: stovetop Time: 1-2 hours. That is a good thought and I will try it soon, just to see how it turns out. If you have leftover sauce, store in an airtight container and stick in the refrigerator. Method: crock pot, stovetop Time: over 5 hours, A bit of brown sugar in the sauce really gets the sweet and savory combo going for these crowd-pleasing hot dogs. Add onion. A chili dog is a hot dog on a bun that is topped with chili con carne. Recipes, techniques, and tips for guaranteed crowd-pleasers! Add the tomato sauce, brown sugar, chili powder, salt and pepper. Its a great recipe I cut back on the sugar a bit and added a quarter tsp of allspice, Thank you!!! Tag me on Instagram. I sent you an email with it. Please visit #OverTheMoon on Sunday or #ThursdayFavoriteThings for more sharing fun! Learn how your comment data is processed. brown sugar, 1/2 c. catsup, 1/3 c. tomato sauce. We had not tried it with the turkey. My husband loves them. He will be making it to take to Deer Camp next fall. condiment bottle. Some of our other favorite foods to serve at a cookout areBest Baked Beans Recipe,Raspberry Pretzel Salad,Hawaiian Macaroni Salad, and Classic Frog Eye Salad! I couldnt eat it..too spicy hot for me..haha They found the recipe folded up in a bible. Say goodbye to mushy hot dogs. It is way too hot for us too. Online since 1995, CDKitchen has grown into a large collection of delicious recipes created by home cooks and professional chefs from around the world. Stir in 1/2 cup hoisin sauce, 2 tablespoons each rice vinegar and dry sherry, 1 tablespoon each soy sauce and ketchup and 1/3 cup water. Thank you for checking it out. What do you normally eat on hot dogs? Over medium heat, saute diced onion and garlic in olive oil in a large saute pan or Dutch oven. Store in the refrigerator for up to 2 months. Bring to a boil and then let the sauce simmer for about 5 minutes until it has thickened. Hi. I am not familiar with the ones you mention, but I bet they are so good! Beef, tomato sauce, and onions spiced up with a few choice seasonings make a hearty hot dog topping. Thank you. J Dawgs started as a little hot dog stand in a shack south of campus in 2004 during my senior year. If you are following a medically restrictive diet, please consult your doctor or registered dietitian before preparing this recipe for personal consumption. It calls for 1 C. ketchup & 1 C. brown sugar and that seems like a LOT. You know what they say, "the secret is in the sauce?" Transfer to a slow cooker to keep warm for serving. We have a small one. Bring to a boil, uncovered. Tips Cook, stirring occasionally, until hot dogs are cooked through and evenly coated, about 10 minutes. Thank you for checking this out and let me know what you think when you get a chance to make it. You can even use this hot dog chili on a hot dog bar! yellow mustard 2 tsp. My mom used to have a little hot dog shop in the country many years ago, called Sams Hot Dogs. ketchup, brown sugar, garlic salt, cold water, worcestershire sauce and 11 more. Remove from the heat and pour the jdawg's special sauce into a 16 oz. Follow directions above but add everything to the skillet along with the beef. Ive never tried it but I will now! Add the ketchup, tomato paste, soy sauce, chili powder, salt, garlic powder, ground mustard, pepper, onion powder, cumin and cup of water, and stir to combine. Boiling the meat seems to bring a lot of grease out but we just spooned it off, except a little. It is usually a big hit at cook-outs and gatherings. Step 1 Add the ground beef to a skillet on the stovetop. LOLgreat minds. I bet he will *LOVE* this addition! I love homemade hot dog chili. LOL. Add. He usually follows recipes and adds a little of his own personal touch to them, but he told me he wanted to totally create a recipe for homemade hot dog sauce. I Made It. haha. Method: stovetop Time: under 30 minutes, Coney sauce will always take a frank to the next level. And then pair your delicious dog with some french fries. We had a restaurant in my home town that had the best coney dogs. Have ready a small bowl to collect the excess grease. Always looking for good hot dog sauce recipe. Updated: May 27, 2022 by Kevin Williams | Leave a Comment. When I was in law school, it was a quick walk from the law building to the original shack location and its popularity was such that there was always a wait to get one of their amazing creations stuffed with toppings and dripping with their signature sweet J Dawgs hot dog sauce. Bring the sauerkraut to a boil. Incredible Hot Dog Sauce. Thank you. Add cornstarch slurry and simmer 2 minutes more. It's considered to be fairly flavorless which makes it a great liquor for mixed drinks. Grill hot dogs on a preheated grill until they are heated through and have nice char marks. Set aside. We are so honored. Thank you. Looks awesome!!! Im from WV and the hotdog chili sounds like a recipe from Brunswicks. This recipe doubles well, so make a batch of it and take it on your next camping trip or BBQ. This recipe sounds wonderful. Full Recipe. If I get it, Ill let you know. We just had some homemade J-dawgs at a neighbor's house this past weekend here in good ol' Utah. Use this sauce, pickles, and diced onions to make the best tasting hot dog just like J Dawg's hot dogs. After you make this recipe, will you pretty please leave a comment with a star rating? Ive spent almost three decades exploring Amish settlements and kitchens from Maine to Montana and almost everywhere in between. Then a few grocery stores picked it up & now a young couple in that family has the recipe & are selling it like crazy. This search takes into account your taste preferences. Why the sugar doesnt that make it sweet ? This could also be canned with a pressure canner then you would have it on your shelf when you wanted it. If you are not sure, I would just start with a lesser amount like 1/2 cup brown sugar and when you taste it you could add more if desired. Please, enjoy! Never overlook the humble hot dog again in favor of more "grown-up" fare with this sweet & sticky Copycat J Dawgs Hot Dog Sauce. In a small bowl, add the cornstarch and 2 tablespoons of cold water. Method: stovetop Time: 2-5 hours, No more naked hot dogs! Bring to a boil. Thank you. On medium heat, cook everything for 6 minutes more. gwingal. Method: stovetop Time: 30-60 minutes, Made with cayenne pepper, vegetable oil, white onion, garlic, ketchup, mustard, worchestershire sauce Add enough water to just cover the meat. LOL I dont know where he got the recipe but he swears it is the original one. We call it Pearls recipe. If I cant find it, I will get it again from Bobs friend that has it. Thank you . Thanks for sharing!! Then, it's time to simmer, allowing the sauce to reduce and giving all those flavors a moment to meld together. Also enjoyed Yans hotdog stand there too. Bob is so funny! Love buffalo wings? haha. Forget ketchup and mustard, this is the best hot dog sauce recipe ever. Drain. Hot Dog Sauce. Be sure to stir frequently. Thank you Krista. Once tasted ,never forgotten. Carefully crumble beef into water. Season the onion mixture with salt, pepper, and a dash of hot sauce. Remove from heat and allow sauce to cool to room temperature. And please come back soon. How exciting. Pinned and Yummed . Here's the recipe for hot dog sauce so you can make some now. In a medium size bowl, combine the ketchup, Worcestershire sauce, and brown sugar. Hi Sandy, I dont have one for Pearls. this recipe does 3 - 4 dogs, double recipe as needed. What I like about this Amish Sweet Hog Dog Sauce recipe is that it's just so simple nad basic, not some complicated coney formulation. Personally, I like 80/20 Chuck and trimmed lean brisket. Combine all of the sauce ingredients together in a small pan. Oh I love meats cooked on the smoker. It seems to balance the heat in it. Your email address will not be published. , Just to let you know..I didnt forget. Chicken Nuggets with Tangy Sauce - So good! This is coming from the girl who used to HATE hot dogs. I enjoy exploring the world through food, culture, and travel and sharing the adventure with mostly from-scratch, family friendly recipes that I think of as modern comfort cooking. -Marci @ Stone Cottage Adventures. Hey MattI was at a cook-out tonight and they served hot dog sauce from Yans in Fairmont. Hot Dog Sauce Ketchup Brown Sugar Recipes 7,284 Recipes. Add crunchy, cheesy, salty, over-the-top savory Frito Pie to your dinnertime lineup! More Amish Sauce Recipes THAT is it!!!! ), 21 Vodka Cocktails That'll Knock Your Socks Off, 15 Buffalo Wing Flavored Recipes (And Not Just Wings! Ill send it to your email. This will help others find this amazing recipe! A few weeks later we tried it again and used ground sirloin but it was too dry. The beef is quickly browned on the stovetop and then the ketchup goes in. Many years ago my previous neighbor had this recipe. Taste of Home is America's #1 cooking magazine. Add the rest of ingredients and stir and keep on simmer heat for 30 minutes, stirring occasionally. Stir in tomato sauce, ketchup, salt, pepper, sugar, and chili powder; bring to a boil. Please let me know if it seems close to her recipe if you get to make it. My Handsome Husband likes to smoke meats and does a little side job catering, pulling his big smoker onsite. This is a weekly collection of recipes shared by amazing cooks/bakers. No I have not. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. Dont use canned chili, used a good chili on your dogs! Your recipe is much like Greek cooking. (-) Information is not currently available for this nutrient. Cover and cook on high for 1.5 hours or low for 3 hours. and sometimes with the extra diced onions. Drain any fat. mustard (regular liquid mustard) 2 tsp. Very promising but now just a sweet disaster. We used to have two Coney Island restaurants(now down to one) both owned by Greeks and their sauce is the very best. Stir in 1 Tbsp each yellow mustard and ketchup, and then cup water. I hadnt thought to mix the two types of ground meat. And the star attraction of such events? Some people do prefer it to be less sweet using less brown sugar. Jill Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Only a 2-3 more minutes of simmering and you're all set to serve! Thanks for sharing!! Add in 1/3 cup of broth. Im from Jackson Michigan we are famous for coney sauce. * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. I used 1# ground turkey and 1# ground round and it turned out very tasty! This sweet hot dog sauce recipe also works very well on veggie dogs. Hi, my name is Kevin Williams and I am owner of Oasis Newsfeatures and editor of The Amish Cook newspaper column. Thanks. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Welcome to Amish365, where I share my knowledge of Amish cooking and culture! Bring to a boil and then let the sauce simmer for about 5 minutes until it has thickened. Someone else mentioned it to me on another site. We appreciate you sharing your goodness! Hubby and I both love coney dogs and this recipe sounds awesome. Amish365 has another hot dog sauce recipe, it's a little less sweetcheck it out! Stir everything together and simmer, uncovered, for 1.5 hours. The sauce can be refrigerated for a week or two if you have any leftover. I was wondering about trying it in a crock pot. I like cole slaw on mine and he likes the mustard and onions. Add in garlic, tomato paste, chili powder, salt, pepper and cumin and cook for 2-3 minutes. Thanks Pam. Sweet Peanut Butter Dessert Sauce Crisco. It is sure a personal preference on adding the brown sugar and how much. Definitely going to make this, love a good chili dog!! 5402 views. Offer toppings such as shredded cheddar cheese, minced onion, jalapenos, mustard (try it! I share simple holiday and family fun ideas so you can create more memories together. My name is Pamela, but I am known to many as Grandma Honey. Oh my gosh!!! Reduce heat to a simmer. Brown beef and onion in a large skillet over medium-high heat. Would it work if I put them in with the ground beef when browning the ground beef? I told him that I had a wonderful neighbor years ago (Lou Ann) who had the best homemade hot dog sauce recipe. condiment bottle. Im pretty sure I have the original sauce recipe from WV you mentioned. Im going to call her and see if I can get it. Coney Sauce, Hot Dog Chili, Hot Dog Sauce, Southern Old-Fashioned Cornbread Dressing | Thanksgiving Recipe. In a large saute pan over medium-high heat, add the ground beef and break it apart using a wooden spoon. She was from Williamson or Kermit and her husband was the other townI forget which one was from where. Directions. Keywords: hot dogs, hot dog sauce, j dawgs, bbq. Add water or ketchup if it thickens too much. I would love to have the recipe. Prepping for a backyard cookout? This hot dog sauce is a JDawg's special sauce copycat recipe. Method: stovetop Time: 1-2 hours, Texans take their hot dogs seriously, and that's why they have their own sauce recipe. Instead of adding the meat and ingredients to the slow cooker add right to the pan. Congrats to both of you!This wonderful recipe is being featured with most clicks received from last week. We love a good sauce and love trying different ones too. Do you love chili dogs? One thing I like on an occasional basis is a chili dog. The second attempt was an adjustment on spices. I moved to Indiana and the hot dog sauce out here sucks. Stir the catsup, tomato sauce, and brown sugar over medium heat for 5 minutes and then turn burner down to simmer. To really do it right, a healthy ladle of sweet, savory Coney sauce with beef and tomatoes is what you need. In a bowl, mix the ketchup, brown sugar, mustard, and vinegar until blended. Double the recipe to fill a 16 0z. Brown the meat and crumble as small as you can. This recipe was great until the brown sugar addition. This recipe is definitely a keeper. This may burn if you leave it unattended too long. Now keep in mind, when these recipes call for catsup or pasta sauce, in an Amish kitchen, this usually means homemade versions from the canning closet. Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce. The cornstarch slurry is what thickens the coney sauce and it is perfect for a quick-fix chili as it is both fast-acting and flavorless. It originated inasmalltown in WV and was served in a popular restaurant there.